What Makes Us Happy? / The Atlantic / 2009 Best Article
{This is post #3 of 31 for The Best of 2009 Blog Challenge - Get Started Now.}
The take home lesson is to always enjoy where you are. Now. Happiness is love. Full stop. - Dr. George Vaillant
I stopped by the pharmacy to buy a box of tea. The tea section is next to the magazines. I rarely read The Atlantic but saw the headline, "What Makes Us Happy?" I read the first few lines standing. Absorbed, I sat down and read the article to its finish and then I cried in the tea section of the pharmacy.
Is there a recipe for a good life?
If there is a recipe for happiness, the man who conducted the study, Dr. George Vaillant, knows the ingredients and how to combine them. "The project is one of the longest-running—and probably the most exhaustive—longitudinal studies of mental and physical well-being in history. Begun in 1937 as a study of healthy, well-adjusted Harvard sophomores (all male), it has followed its subjects for more than 70 years," writes the author, Joshua Wolf Shenk.
Rereading the article today, it is first the content, of course, that strikes me. This is an article about a remarkable group of men, a remarkable amount of data collected over a tremendous amount of time. But it is Shenk's ability to weave narrative, notes, data, vignettes of these men's lives and their struggles - into a cohesive and compelling whole - that makes it worth reading. And worth studying.
The art of curating
The word "curate" has come into vogue this as The New York Times points out in, "The Word 'Curate' No Longer Belongs to the Museum Crowds." Now it's trendy to see yourself as "curating" your world. "The word “curate,” lofty and once rarely spoken outside exhibition corridors or British parishes," writes Alex Williams in the article, "has become a fashionable code word among the aesthetically minded, who seem to paste it onto any activity that involves culling and selecting."
But this man, Dr. Vaillant, shown through Shenk's lens, is no fly by night hipster curator. He has dedicated his life to the Grant Study. "For 42 years, the psychiatrist George Vaillant has been the chief curator of these lives, the chief investigator of their experiences, and the chief analyst of their lessons." And the article succeeds in sharing a glimpse of what Vaillant has discovered over the years.
The Rounding Influence of Storytelling
"If it was to come to life," writes Shenk, "this cleaver-sharp science project would need the rounding influence of storytelling. In George Vaillant, the Grant Study found its storyteller, and in the Grant Study, Vaillant found a set of data, and a series of texts, suited to his peculiar gifts." I would argue that even the best storyteller needs a vessel to get his story to a larger audience. I believe Shenk's article gave a vessel and a life to the story that it may not have otherwise gotten.
Best article for 2009: What Makes Us Happy? by Joshua Wolf Shenk at The Atlantic
Notable Mentions: three more projects on happiness that caught my attention this year:
- Gretchen Rubin's Happiness Project (in which I'm humbled to have been featured)
- The Geography of Bliss - Eric Weiner
- Unlikely Friends
- Bonus: The best book on writing I read this year - Telling True Stories: A Nonfiction Writers' Guide
Quotes from the video from Dr. Vaillant, if you don't have time to watch the video right now:
"Put yourself in positions where positive emotions are likely. You can take up gardening, where what you're trying to do is make the poor little plants grow. Not win prizes at the horticulture shows. As soon as the gardening becomes doing it for me, then you get third prize and the best garden club in town doesn't invite you when you're life sucks."
"It's alright that young people can do the things that they can do. The youth that the old envy is accompanied by the miserable process of getting from twenty-five to thirty-five. We've got all this health and all this youth, and you're scared stiff, that when it's all said and done you're not going to amount to a hill of beans."
{Subscribe to daily posts from gwenbell.com}
Thursday, December 3, 2009
3 Comments 













Reader Comments (3)
I like the concept of "curating" your life or situation if for no other reason than it gives you some feeling of order and peace. I think many designers approach our lives that way. I certainly try to. I remember the (now defunct) magazine Blueprint, published by Martha Stewart, had a "Design Your Life" tagline.
This sounds like a great piece. Though it's disappointing that the study consisted of men. I wonder if there is an equivalent for women? Have you heard about the PBS series that's going to debut in January- http://www.pbs.org/thisemotionallife/ I don't watch much TV, but I'm really intrigued by it.
I love your Best of 09 Challenge. Off to finish my post for Day 4!
This is a great video and blog. It's gratifying, but not at all surprising, that his conclusions are so in sync with Yoga philosophy, as I've tried to capture on my website. It's all about the present moment and feeling connected to the universe and to others. I even wrote a piece called "What is It That Brings Us Happiness?" http://wp.me/PlUox-f0 , based on the ancient Yoga texts, that emphasizes, like Vaillant, concentration, egolessness, and connection.
(Not to be a curmudgeon, but any group of 268 Harvard graduates is hardly representative of society as a whole. It leaves out a whole gender, for one thing, as a previous commenter pointed out. Plus anyone who even gets into Harvard is already in a highly privileged and relatively homogeneous group, especially back before universities made a point of trying to diversify their student body. So I doubt the study has much scientific validity unless compared to other studies. This is only one very limited and very lucky segment of society. But it is very interesting and relevant nonetheless.)
Thanks for posting.
Bob Weisenberg
http://YogaDemystified.com